Will Polston on The Mindset Shift Bookkeepers Need to Scale

Will Polston doesn’t talk about business growth as a tactics problem. In his interview on The Bookkeepers’ Podcast (sponsored by Xero), he frames growth as a performance and identity challenge: what an owner believes is possible, what they’re willing to take responsibility for, and what they consistently measure.

In conversation with Zoe Whitman and Jo Wood, Will shares how entrepreneurs unlock their next level, and why bookkeepers, in particular, can use the same framework to price with confidence, sell higher-value support, and build a practice that doesn’t depend on them doing everything.

Who is Will Polston?

Will Polston is a business strategist and performance coach who works with entrepreneurs on “potential, performance and purpose.” He’s also built and operated multiple businesses across sectors, including a renewable energy company that scaled quickly before a legislation change wiped it out, and later product-based ventures such as a mushroom supplement business created through partnerships and network-led opportunities.

That mix of coaching + real-world entrepreneurship is why this interview lands so strongly for bookkeepers: it’s grounded in what actually happens when businesses grow — not just what looks good on a strategy slide.

The core idea: growth starts when responsibility becomes non-negotiable

One of the most quotable moments in the interview is Will’s view that the turning point for any business owner is taking 100% responsibility for what’s happening, without slipping into blame or victim thinking.

He describes responsibility as “response-ability”: the ability to respond. In practice, that means when business results aren’t where they need to be, the question becomes:

  • “What can be changed?”
  • “What’s within control?”
  • “What’s the next decision that moves this forward?”

For bookkeepers, this is especially relevant because the work can pull them into reactive delivery (deadlines, queries, client panic). Will’s framework flips the mindset back to: the owner sets the direction, and the practice follows.

The “identity shift”

Will highlights a subtle but powerful change: moving from the identity of “I’m a bookkeeper” to “I’m the owner of a bookkeeping business.”

Identity drives behaviour. If someone identifies as “a bookkeeper,” they naturally focus on doing bookkeeping. However, if they identify as “a business owner,” they’re more likely to:

  • market consistently
  • create packages and boundaries
  • track KPIs
  • build partnerships
  • hire and delegate
  • sell outcomes, not tasks

This ties directly to the biggest challenges many bookkeepers face: underpricing, scope creep, inconsistent marketing, and doing too much themselves.

Why a “North Star” plan beats a detailed business plan

Will explains that he’s a believer in a North Star: a clear life mission and trajectory, then reverse-engineering goals and milestones, even if the exact route isn’t known yet.

He shares an example that surprises many listeners: he once set a goal to build and sell a business for a specific amount without knowing what the business would be. Over time, the type of business became clearer, and eventually an opportunity emerged that fit the plan.

For bookkeepers, the takeaway is practical:

  • it’s possible to plan without knowing every step
  • clarity comes from direction, not perfection
  • the point is to create a trajectory that guides decisions

The KPI framework bookkeepers can steal: leading vs lagging metrics

Will breaks down performance measurement in a way that maps beautifully to bookkeeping practices.

He distinguishes between:

  • Lagging metrics: results that reflect the past (e.g., year-end accounts, last month’s profit)
  • Leading metrics: actions that predict the future (e.g., outreach, ad spend, content published, calls booked)

He also shares a simple operating flow:

  • track key numbers weekly (a “scoreboard”)
  • review financial reports by the 10th of each month
  • compare actual performance to targets, not just “what happened”

That point is particularly sharp: profit isn’t automatically “good”, it depends on what the target was. A month can look fine on paper while the business is quietly missing its plan.

For bookkeepers wanting to grow, this creates an immediate action:

  • choose 3–5 leading metrics (marketing + sales activity)
  • choose 3–5 lagging metrics (revenue + profit + capacity)
  • review weekly so small adjustments happen fast

The advisory opportunity many bookkeepers miss (because clients “don’t know what they don’t know”)

A standout section of the interview is Will’s reflection on his early experiences with accountants: he received compliance support, but no one introduced the proactive tools that help businesses stay stable and grow.

He mentions examples like:

  • 13-week cash flow forecasting
  • monthly profit and loss forecast comparisons
  • tracking customer acquisition cost and lifetime value
  • understanding labour-to-turnover ratios

For bookkeepers, this is both a business opportunity and a positioning advantage.

Will suggests a very simple tactic that bookkeepers can use immediately: a short questionnaire for prospects that asks whether they have key reporting and forecasting in place. Even asking the questions creates a “lightbulb moment” for the business owner, and positions the bookkeeper as the one who can lead them forward.

Why weekly reporting creates faster growth

Will’s argument for weekly reporting is compelling: if a business only reviews performance monthly, that’s 12 optimisation opportunities a year. Weekly reviews create around 48 opportunities to adjust.

For a bookkeeping business, that can mean:

  • spotting a marketing slump before revenue dips
  • seeing scope creep patterns quickly
  • tracking capacity before burnout hits
  • noticing cash flow pressure early

This is one of those “simple but not easy” ideas: it doesn’t require fancy tools — just a decision to operate like a CEO, not a technician.

So, what next?

This interview is packed with ideas that translate directly to building a profitable practice:

  1. Take full responsibility for growth — the owner is the driver.
  2. Make the identity shift from “bookkeeper” to “owner of a bookkeeping business.”
  3. Use a North Star to guide decisions even when the route isn’t clear.
  4. Track leading + lagging metrics so growth becomes predictable, not hopeful.
  5. Introduce advisory via awareness: clients don’t know what they don’t know.
  6. Review weekly to create more chances to optimise and stay on plan.

The next level

Will’s message is simple but challenging: the next stage of growth often requires doing different work, less delivery, more leadership. That means choosing targets, measuring progress, and building a business structure that supports the life the owner wants to live.

Catch the full interview on The Bookkeepers’ Podcast or find out more about Will on his website.

Share this article

Related Posts

Jo Wood, Zoe Whitman and some of the community of Bookkeepers and Accountants

Read our Reviews on Trustpilot

If you’ve been thinking about joining The Bookkeepers’ Collective, you probably already know that the membership includes a huge amount of support, more than 14